Almost perfect. Fit was snug but easily broke in with little to no discomfort. Colours were as pictured exactly. Only complaint was slight rough stitching finish on the inside of the shaft but only on one side of each boot. Some small fraying of stitching that just looks a little rough but not integrally compromising. Only other thing was some unevenness to the brass nailing on the out sole. Left boot had perfect rows of nails right in line with each other right back to under the heal. While the right boot had a bit of a jumble up of 3 nails right near the heel. Not a big deal just something to note. All in all they are great fitting, great looking, and rugged boots ready for the saddle, farm, yard, trail, or Saturday night. Would definitely recommend!